• Home
  • Blog
  • Pets Are Not Gifting Items: Why Surprise Pets Often Suffer

Pets Are Not Gifting Items: Why Surprise Pets Often Suffer

A puppy with a ribbon around its neck.
A kitten inside a basket waiting to jump out.

Pets are not gifting items

We’ve all seen those “aww” moments in movies or on Instagram. They look magical — a living, breathing surprise gift.

But here’s the truth no one talks about: pets are not gifting items. They are living beings with needs, emotions, and a lifelong commitment attached.

When pets are gifted without thought, it’s not just a “surprise.” It can turn into a heartbreaking story — for both the animal and the unprepared family.

🎁 The Problem with “Pet Surprises”

When someone gifts a pet, they often focus only on the cute moment of giving.
What they forget is pets are not gifting items:

  • The receiver may not be emotionally ready.
  • Their home might not have space for a pet.
  • Their lifestyle may not allow the time, patience, or financial commitment pets demand.

👉 And who pays the price for this? The pet.

🐾 A Pet Is Not Like a Gadget

If you gift someone a gadget and they don’t like it, it goes back in the box or is returned.
But when the gift is a living being, it can’t just be “returned” without consequences.

I’ve seen pets:

  • Left tied outside the house because the family wasn’t ready.
  • Ignored because the new “owner” never wanted the responsibility.
  • Abandoned in shelters when the novelty wore off.

This isn’t fair. Pets deserve love, care, and a forever home — not to be treated like surprise showpieces.

❤️ A Family Member, Not an Item

When Fido came home, I didn’t see him as “something I got.”
He was a new family member.
He needed a bed, food, medical care, and—above all—time, patience, and unconditional love.

That’s the responsibility every pet parent takes on.
So if you’re thinking about gifting a pet, remember:
Would you “gift” a baby to someone? No. Then why a puppy or a kitten? Pets are not gifting items.

🚨 What Can Happen to Gifted Pets

Here’s the reality that’s often hidden behind the initial excitement:

  • Unpreparedness → Improper diet, no vet visits, lack of training.
  • Stress for the animal → They don’t understand why they’re in a new place with people who may not want them.
  • Neglect → Many gifted pets are under-socialized and left alone.
  • Abandonment → Shelters see a rise in surrenders right after festivals, birthdays, or holidays.

🌟 What to Do Instead

If you truly want to give the gift of pet companionship:

  1. Talk First – Make sure the family/person wants a pet and is prepared.
  2. Gift Preparedness – Instead of a pet, give:
    • A pet care book
    • A gift card to a pet supply store
    • A “Pet Parenting Starter Kit” (bowls, leash, bed, toys)
    • Or even sponsor adoption fees (so they can choose).
  3. Adopt Together – If they’re ready, let them experience the joy of choosing their companion.
  4. If they were or are Pet Parents: You may take risk of gifting another or new pet but still its better to ask them first. 🙂

💬 Final Thought

A pet isn’t a surprise. It’s a commitment of 10–15 years.
If you want to gift someone joy, give them memories, experiences, or even pet-friendly accessories.

But if you want to gift them a living being… stop. Think twice.
Because the worst thing we can do is bring a pet into a home where love, time, and care are missing.

🐾 Pets aren’t gifts. They are family.
And family deserves thought, preparation, care and respect.

If you know someone planning to gift a pet, share this with them. Together, let’s build a world where pets are welcomed as family — not as surprises.

Hi, I’m Sneha Mutha, lifelong animal lover and founder of The First Paw 🐾. My Labrador, Fido first walked into my life and changed it forever. Now, I’m on a mission to guide other pet parents through this confusing but beautiful journey — from essentials and training to travel and heartwarming stories. When I’m not writing, you’ll find me petting every animal I meet (except lizards 😅)

“I’m here to walk beside you as you discover the beautiful chaos of pet parenting.”


September 6, 2025
Sneha